Season 4 of The Magicians is in unwritten territory – and it’s spellbinding

18 February 2019

Season 4 of The Magicians is in unwritten territory – and it’s spellbinding

  • The Magicians moves beyond the Lev Grossman books it’s based on
  • 100% critics rating on Rotten Tomatoes
  • Every season nominated as Best Fantasy Series by the Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy and Horror Movies
  • Already renewed for fifth season
  • New season offers two villains – The Library, and Eliot The Monster – plus magical witness protection; a suicidal Santa; and much more…

The first four episodes of the fourth season of The Magicians, Syfy’s cult adult fantasy series, are now first and only on Showmax, with new episodes coming weekly, express from the USA.

The first three seasons, also available to stream on Showmax, were based on Lev Grossman’s award-winning trilogy of bestselling fantasy novels – dubbed “Harry Potter for grown-ups” by The Guardian.

Season 4 is now in unwritten territory but, thankfully, in the safe hands of showrunners Sera Gamble (You) and John McNamara (Trumbo), “the result is just as spellbinding as ever,” to quote Indiewire. Critics are unanimous in their agreement: Season 4 currently has a 100% critics rating on Rotten Tomatoes, as did Season 3.

Here are four ways things have changed this season:

1. Your favourite Brakebills alumni are now in witness protection

The Magicians - Season 4 on Showmax

Pictured: Summer Bishil as Margo Hanson — (Photo by: Eric Milner/SYFY)

After helping to bring magic back last season, Julia (Stella Maeve), Kady (Jade Tailor), Margo (Summer Bishil), Penny (Arjun Gupta) and Josh (Trevor Einhorn) aren’t being paraded as heroes: instead, they’re in a magical version of witness protection, with new faces, fake memories and no magic.

As AVClub says, “How do you keep a show fresh, season after season? One method: Wipe the memories of all of your core characters. The Magicians starts its fourth season off having given our favorite misfit magic practitioners a hard reboot… They find themselves in a range of very earth-bound situations, all of which feel very broad—the spacey DJ, the mean magazine editor, the goofy Uber driver, etc.—until it’s revealed that they’re all based on characters in a pulpy comic book. This being The Magicians, obviously they’re going to be trapped in some kind of pop culture reference.”

2. Magic is back, but it’s rationed

The Magicians - Season 4 on Showmax

Pictured: Kacey Rohl as Marina — (Photo by: Eric Milner/SYFY)

Magic is now being rationed by The Library, the ultimate bureaucrats, whose attempts to keep the world safe and ordered are looking increasingly fascist.

As Den of Geek put it, Season 4 returns “to a world that is thankful to have magic back and terrified to have it taken away again… This atmosphere of fear is the perfect breeding ground for fascist rule, and the Library, and Mageina Tovah’s Zelda in particular, is more than happy to step into the role of the benevolent but controlling protector of magic.” As Marina (Kacey Rohl) says in the trailer, “The vibe I’m getting is very 1984.”

Or as The Hollywood Reporter says, “the tyrannical Library… are probably the Biggest Bads of the entire series.”

3. Eliot looks the same, but isn’t

The Magicians Season 4 on Showmax

Hale Appleman as Eliot Waugh — (Photo by: Eric Milner/SYFY)

Eliot (Hale Appleman) is possessed by The Monster, who’s forcing Quentin (Jason Ralph) to help him hunt gods.

As Indiewire puts it, “Appleman as the Monster is a revelation. Never once does he backslide into Eliot mode; instead, through subtle shifts in tone and expression, he becomes the Monster wearing an Eliot suit. This makes his actions even more disturbing as he forces Quentin — whose new identity is a bookish professor named Brian — to be his playmate in murder and mayhem. When the Monster wants to play, woe to those who don’t comply. His retaliation is swift and brutal.”

4. Alice is in jail, one cell down from Santa

The Magicians Season 4 on Showmax

Pictured: Olivia Taylor Dudley as Alice — (Photo by: Eric Milner/SYFY)

Alice (Olivia Taylor Dudley) is in prison, one cell down from a black, suicidal Santa Claus (Tom Wright). To quote Decibel, “For those who haven’t watched The Magicians before, the show doesn’t shy away from edgy subject matter, but suicidal Santa is definitely another level…”

Never watched the Magicians before? Here’s why it’s worth bingeing from Season 1:

The Magicians - Season 4 on Showmax

Pictured: Jason Ralph as Quentin Coldwater — (Photo by: Eric Milner/SYFY)

The Magicians has been nominated as Best Fantasy Series by the Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy and Horror Movies for three years in a row – and, based on the early reviews, seems on track for a fourth straight nomination this year.

Den of Geek gushed, “This fresh take on the characters we love with their new identities is like re-discovering The Magicians all over again. Every moment and every subplot was a pure joy!” The Hollywood Reporter were “enthralled” and praised it as “weird, funny and beautiful… Both a critique and pastiche of high fantasy.” And Indiewire hailed it as “still the funniest fantasy show on TV.”

It’s even winning over people who didn’t fall under the show’s spell in Season 1. As Kathryn VanArendonk, writing for Vulture, admitted, “I quit watching The Magicians and that was a huge mistake… When I came back to it this time… I gulped two seasons in less than a week, and at one point in season three found myself so overcome that I swaddled my entire head in my cardigan and shook with joy. I watched the first three episodes of season four provided to critics much too quickly, and I cannot wait for the rest.”

Syfy recently renewed The Magicians for a fifth season. “The Magicians raised the bar at Syfy and has gained momentum season after season,” says Bill McGoldrick, president of scripted content at NBCUniversal Cable Entertainment.

Start watching now »

The Winning Ticket, a Showmax Original
Youngins S1 episodes 1-20 recap